PDA

View Full Version : IGN's DIGIMON DS ratings



veemon-tamer
11-24-2006, 05:56 PM
I'm not sure rather to be happy or sad... to me it kinda seems like it's being pond off as a game just to play untill pokemon gets here. and it's always being compared to pokemon. i hate that.

---------------------------------------------------------------
http://ds.ign.com/articles/747/747449p1.html
---------------------------------------------------------------

Digimon World DS Review

Waiting for Pokemon? This might tide you over.
by Jack DeVries

November 22, 2006 - It has long been a source of contention among fans of Digimon and Pokemon over which role playing game series is better. Who came first? Which anime has better voice work? Who would win in a deathmatch: Charizard or Wargreymon? (The answer to the last question is, of course, the fans.) the guys over at BEC have come through with a win for the Digimon side… for now. Digimon World DS beat Pokemon to the Nintendo handheld and despite its derivative nature and somewhat mediocre elements, it's still a lot of fun.

The game starts off with the player's character researching this "digital monster thing" on the internet, and getting sucked into the magical (or is it technological?) world of Digimon. And I don't mean "sucked in" like a nerdy teenager becomes engrossed with World of Warcraft and forgets to eat. I mean the player is literally sucked into the computer through the screen and ends up in a new universe. What should be a harrowing and traumatic experience is taken very well and soon players are off to go explore and talk to any strange, bipedal monster that crosses his or her path.

Turns out that Digimon is the hot new fad that's sweeping the globe! Everyone wants to be sucked into their PCs without warning and immediately placed in dangerous situations. Where do I sign up?! The first few minutes of the game are out of the player's control, as the character walks around automatically, learning the basics of the world and how they work. Digitrainers are given objects called Digivices, as well as a companion Digimon which they can raise on the DigiFarm, and feed DigiFood (yeah, I'm already sick of the prefix too). Players can battle other Digimon, and add them to their collection, and all the Digimon can "digivolve" into stronger monsters.

If this sounds a lot like that other collectible fighting monster game, it's because it is.

That isn't to say that Digimon should be written off as a ripoff game, because it is still pretty fun. This is a solid RPG, presented in an isometric view. There are lots of areas to explore, and people to talk to. The game even has a good deal of humor. MY personal favorite is when one of the evil monsters threatened to kill a young girl.

"Over my dead Digimon!" was my characters reply.

Digimon does a lot of things very similar to the Pokemon series, but also tries to pull away from being a complete ripoff. In fact, Digimon World does a few things that separate the game from Pokemon quite a bit. One of the things players are going to notice is that all the Digimon talk. In fact, conversing with Digimon becomes an integral part of the game. Talking to the monsters increases friendship and lowers stress. The Digimon will also occasionally give you quests to complete. By doing the quests, players not only make the little monsters happy, but also earn points for items.




In the more traditional RPG sense, the Digimon can be equipped with items and weapons. The weapons offer up new special attacks. Some weapons are for certain monster types, and others have level requirements. In addition, armor and accessories can also be equipped, allowing players to customize their Digimon to create the ultimate fighting team.

The layout of the battles is also significantly different. Players can have up to six Digimon in their party. The first three monsters are the ones that enter into battle. How many Digimon players have in their party determines the number enemies that pop up. Having the first three slots filled often means the monsters will be battling enemies in packs of three. This keeps the battles more balanced, but also offers up a more efficient way to earn experience. The battles are pretty basic, with sprites representing all the monsters, and overlaying attack animations. The lines are sharp and the colors are vibrant. The backgrounds represent the area players are exploring, so it looks like you're fighting a giant bug in a jungle, not in a void.

Thankfully, there are no "digiballs" used to catch new monsters. Instead, every time players encounter a Digimon, it gets scanned and data is gathered on it. After around 8-10 encounters, players have enough information to convert the data into their own copy of the Digimon. It's an interesting way to do it, and allows players to have a full party of monsters and not have to worry about not being able to catch any more. On the downside, some of the more rare Digimon will take some time to collect, since it will be a while before players encounter one enough times.

When players digiconvert a new monster, it can be placed in the DigiFarm to be raised. Here the Digimon will eat, and train, gaining experience while the other Digimon are off doing important missions. The feature is kind of cool since it allows players to raise Digimon without having to battle them, and makes sure no Digimon goes to waste. Managing the farm is less cool. Pretty early in the game, players will have to spend a lot of hard earned cash if they want to be able to support all their Digimon. It's a feature that ultimately also proves unnecessary, so spending all that money seems silly when switching the Digimon out and training it for a little bit is faster, cheaper, and easier.

Unlike Pokemon, a lot of the Digimon have options when it comes to Digivolving. Players pick when the little guys get to change form, and can wait until the monster reaches certain requirements to change into a beter, stronger monster. This also encourages players to catch multiple versions of the basic Digimon early, since they can sometimes be changed into three different monsters.

The game boasts Nintendo Wi-Fi Connection capabilities, though it's limited to Digimatching. By sharing friends codes, players can have their Digimon make sweet Digilove and produce one of a variety of Digieggs. There are also wireless battles, trading, and training, though none of those are over the wifi connection. It's a shame too, because that could have been a major selling point for the game, especially with Pokemon Diamond and Pearl not out yet.

For a Nintendo DS game, the music in Digimon World isn't too bad. It all has that vaguely techno sound to it, reminiscent of some of the old Sonic the Hedgehog level soundtracks (Casino Night meets Metropolis). There isn't any voice work, and the Digimon don't make much noise, even during battle, but considering how many times players battle, that might be a good thing.


Closing Comments
For players that are dying to get their monster battling RPG fix, Digimon World should be a welcome addition to their library, at least until Pokemon Diamond and Pearl. The game may still be a ripoff of Pokemon, despite developer's attempts to set it apart, but it still is a fun game. If it had more internet capabilities, it could have been one of the better RPGs on the DS. But until Pokemon Diamond and Pearl come, this will have to Digi-do for now.

IGN Ratings for Digimon World DS (DS)
Rating Description
out of 10 click here for ratings guide

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
7.0 Presentation
Lots of humor in the game makes it enjoyable to read the dialogue. The story is pretty shallow, but it gets the job done.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
7.0 Graphics
Doesn't push the DS's limits, but it does look pretty nice. The battles are simple, but stylized, and the environments are vibrant.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
6.0 Sound
The music is pretty cool, but the songs to sound pretty similar to each other. There isn't any voice work, but hundreds of different animal squawks is annoying anyway.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
8.0 Gameplay
Very solid RPG with a lot of customization options. The branching evolution chains is a nice touch that makes every player's party unique.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
6.0 Lasting Appeal
The wifi options is pretty weak, which is a shame. There is still a ton of stuff to do though, and players can battle, trade, and train through the DS to DS connection.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
7.5
Good OVERALL
(out of 10 / not an average)
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------


What do yall think?
IMO i don't think it was judged on a fair bases. I think it might have lost some points from being compared to pokemon too much...HELLO PEOPLE THE WORLD DON"T REVOLVE AROUND DAMN DAIMOND AND PEARL. THE MONSTERS ARE STARTING TO LOOK UGLY,UNCREATIVE, AND THE GAMEPLAY LOOKS THE SAME AS YEARS AGO. I think digimon ds is a refreashing change of pace that can be enjoyed even if you aint waiting for pokemon. Just my thoughts.
but, i guess i like the rating it got I just wish it would stop being constantly compared to pokemon.

Terriermon Fan
11-24-2006, 06:15 PM
I don't like their review.

Mostly because they hint at saying that it's a ripoff (Well, atleast that is what I am thinking when I am reading it. Even though they stated otherwise. Then again, I could be overeacting.). I mean, what does Pokemon have to do with this game? Game reviewers should know better than to compare two things. Eh, the score is more or less okay. Just the review they gave it was sad. Although, I agree with the score they gave it on the Wifi department.

Leon Kennedy
11-24-2006, 06:20 PM
IGN's pretty lenient with their reviews.

Trust me, you'll find A LOT worse elsewhere.

Anubimon
11-24-2006, 07:15 PM
It was a fair review, I think. Their criticisms are quite valid. The constant comparison to Pokemon was a bit annoying, but it makes sense. Pokemon is the best game to compare it to.

SakuyamonX
11-24-2006, 07:32 PM
At least it got better reviews... What did Digimon World 4/X get?

Unknown Neo
11-24-2006, 07:34 PM
Yes but wasn't 4/X bad. And that's a fair review. Very fair.

SakuyamonX
11-24-2006, 07:49 PM
Yes but wasn't 4/X bad.

That's the point =P

IIRC it got a 6.1

RewolfJ
11-24-2006, 08:07 PM
Always remember: The people qualified and well educated enough to write accurate video game reviews are off writing something more important.
If you really want to know if a game is right for you, research it. Don't go to the game's board on IGN or GameFAQ's and ask if you should get it though. Most of the users are there because they enjoy it and will tell you to get it. Ask what sucks about it instead. You'll get more facts that way.

DigiMatt
11-24-2006, 08:09 PM
Digimon/Pokemon comparison has been around since day one(when I was in 4th grade, and I'm graduating this year). To see it publicised is annoying as well.

By gosh, why don't we just compare Pokemon and Digimon to Cock Fighting of the old days? Setting roosters against roosters and all that jazz. That'll get Hillary Clinton's blood pressure up.

SakuyamonX
11-24-2006, 08:14 PM
Always remember: The people qualified and well educated enough to write accurate video game reviews are off writing something more important.
If you really want to know if a game is right for you, research it. Don't go to the game's board on IGN or GameFAQ's and ask if you should get it though. Most of the users are there because they enjoy it and will tell you to get it. Ask what sucks about it instead. You'll get more facts that way.

So true. One can notice the negatives more, then the positives... (Especilly some people that I won't mention =P)

Airdra
11-24-2006, 08:57 PM
Really, if the author just had to do the comparison, it might have been best to corral it all into one paragraph instead of scattering it throughout the whole thing. But hey, at least it's a positive review, right? ^^;;

MugenSeiRyuu
11-25-2006, 06:00 AM
What did you expect ? Most of the so called Game Experts are Idiots who don´t know what they are talking about. And I´m a nice person calling them Idiots.

As for WarGreymon vs. Charizard: WarGreymon shouldn´t use Gaia Force. That just ruins the leather and makes Charizard´s corpse wothless.

Edit: Just look at that Bastard´s Review:

Digimon World DS

http://readerreviews.ign.com/rrview/games/digimon_world_ds/761624/53437/
Not a very good game.
by ShadowEclipse53
This Review's Trust Rating: 0 2
November 18, 2006 - Digimon World DS.....It is hardly any fun to play and I think it is a waste of money. The graphics are no better than the gameboy's. The music is really bad, and the gameplay just freakin sucks. It sucks balls. The battles are very.........boring.....I like Digimon...so I hope they make a better game in the future.
Reader's Ratings for Digimon World DS
Rating Description
out of 10 click here for ratings guide
2.0 Presentation
no..just no
3.0 Graphics
The sprites are small and there is not a lot of detail.
1.0 Sound
My EARS!!!
1.0 Gameplay
Ridiculous.
1.0 Lasting Appeal
You'll stop playing this game after 2 minutes.
3.0 OVERALL
(out of 10 / not an average)

AlforceVeedramon
11-25-2006, 09:20 AM
forget Charizard vs. WarGreymon, I want to see Mewtwo vs. Millenniummon 9_9

MugenSeiRyuu
11-25-2006, 09:28 AM
Mewtwo: I´m Mewtwo ! The Mightiest Pokemon ever created !
Mille: I must think of a way to get my beloved Ryo.*Accidently stomps on Mewtwo* EHHH !

I fear this might turn into another VS.-Thread.

AlforceVeedramon
11-25-2006, 09:50 AM
hmm, come to think of it, who would be AlforceVeedramon's Poke-Opposite... >_>

Airdra
11-25-2006, 01:54 PM
Specific Pokemon versus talk is getting OT...if y'all really want to, go make a separate topic in the VS forum. ^^;;

MugenSeiRyuu
11-25-2006, 04:47 PM
Topic: There are worse Reviews. Far worse.

AlforceVeedramon
11-25-2006, 04:55 PM
how is that possible? Do they all call it a Pokemon clone?

MugenSeiRyuu
11-25-2006, 05:11 PM
A lot do. You can´t expect something good from a review that starts with calling it "an obvious and and blatant Rip-Off or Pokemon". Don´t you think ?

RewolfJ
11-25-2006, 07:07 PM
I could just imagine somebody who has to review this game for a publication:
"Digimon? Isn't that some kind of Mexican rip-off of Pokey-manz? *flips through manual* Okay, it's about collecting and fighting monsters and the franchise title ends in 'mon', it IS a rip off. Since Pokemon is for stupid little kids, I'm just going to make jokes about how I'd rather inflict pain on myself rather than play this game that I assume is just a boring knock-off of some kiddy crap that I'm too macho for."

Regardless, DWDS currently has the seventh most active Nintendo DS message board and is ranked ninth DS game overall. So not only is it selling well, people are enjoying it! Good news for Digimon's revival in North America.

ex-agumon
11-26-2006, 01:51 PM
well guys i love this game!! it is so much better and less boring than a certain mon. ive been playing non stop for 3 days now1 id also like to thank everyone on this site for your help. im enjoying it so much more thanks to you cheers!!! 10 out of 10 love it!!!!!!!!!!!!

reddmann
11-27-2006, 01:20 AM
man i dont know where these reviews are coming from..... i bought the game the day it came out in america..... i have played EVERY day since the release day...... sure not loads of hours each day... but even now i f*cken LOVE this game.... i cant get enough of it!!!!!! 8)

frig..... i cant even explain how much this game rocks..........

DigiMatt
11-27-2006, 01:17 PM
Obviously some of these posts are based on pure fandom.

Sure, love the game. But to love it endlessly without noticing it's obvious faults is, well, ignorant.

1) We want to see our own Digimon unleashing it's array of death.
1b) More sprites. Some attacks tend to look the same
2) No Wi-fi battling
3) A more engaging storyline. It's got it's good points, I suppose. But, if you're going to have the main character speak, give a better story.

Why do you think Pokemon, Legend of Zelda, and other games don't have their main character talk? Because that main character is you, and you can make up the character of the main character yourself. When the story mode is driven by an already characterized character, make the story from themain character's point of view alot more interesting and less straight foreward.

MugenSeiRyuu
11-27-2006, 01:59 PM
The games you mentioned are still straight forward.

DigiMatt
11-27-2006, 02:48 PM
Eh, shoulda made that clearer. Games where the main character doesn't talk should be straight foreward. Like Pokemon, and Zelda, and such. You listen to people, travel around, fight, win.

Games like Kingdom Hearts, .hack//series, and other games with the main character talking have very in depth stories. You know, stories you can theorize with.

Mind you, this doesn't hold true for ALL games, but it's a general rule of thumb. (Get it, thumb? Video games? Oh, forget you) lol

MugenSeiRyuu
11-27-2006, 03:04 PM
It´s actually a relativly deep story. Not as Deep as some others, but keep in mind at what target it is aimed at.

JackSkellington
11-29-2006, 04:20 PM
I stopped trusting IGN after they gave Kingdom Hearts II a 7.3/10.

the comp
12-02-2006, 09:30 AM
What did you expect ? Most of the so called Game Experts are Idiots who don´t know what they are talking about. And I´m a nice person calling them Idiots.

As for WarGreymon vs. Charizard: WarGreymon shouldn´t use Gaia Force. That just ruins the leather and makes Charizard´s corpse wothless.

Edit: Just look at that Bastard´s Review:

Digimon World DS

http://readerreviews.ign.com/rrview/games/digimon_world_ds/761624/53437/
Not a very good game.
by ShadowEclipse53
This Review's Trust Rating: 0 2
November 18, 2006 - Digimon World DS.....It is hardly any fun to play and I think it is a waste of money. The graphics are no better than the gameboy's. The music is really bad, and the gameplay just freakin sucks. It sucks balls. The battles are very.........boring.....I like Digimon...so I hope they make a better game in the future.
Reader's Ratings for Digimon World DS
Rating Description
out of 10 click here for ratings guide
2.0 Presentation
no..just no
3.0 Graphics
The sprites are small and there is not a lot of detail.
1.0 Sound
My EARS!!!
1.0 Gameplay
Ridiculous.
1.0 Lasting Appeal
You'll stop playing this game after 2 minutes.
3.0 OVERALL
(out of 10 / not an average)


now that is an awful reveiw. first of all, by "the sprites look like a gameboy," they had better mean gameboy advance because other wise they have brain damage.

and stop playing after 2 minutes.....yeah right. i was playing the game literally all day yesterday.

Psycho
12-03-2006, 01:07 PM
although it did bother me allt he mentioning of pokemon but it could of been worse.....a lot worse ((I kept noticing how they said it wasnt a rip off))

this may sound completely wrong but now I'm curious...is there a "Hot Coffie" mod for the Digimon matching?

Unknown Neo
12-03-2006, 03:48 PM
I'd say I'd hit you for that joke but that would be mean. So I'll just say no.
(I really dislike GTA.)

Matsuo_Makoto
12-03-2006, 04:01 PM
stop playing after two minutes? Wow my friend got this and he let me borrow it for the night and i stayed up 2 hours longer than i normally would to play lol

Psycho
12-03-2006, 09:00 PM
the only reason I put it down is so I could get to the botto of my own WiFi cunundrum

and sorry about the Hot Coffie joke

Unknown Neo
12-04-2006, 05:23 PM
No problem. I just really don't like that game.

Psycho
12-05-2006, 08:04 AM
I stopped liking GTA when they made racing missions part of the main story

but back on topic right now the only reason for me not playing Digimon World DS is because I'm waiting for WiFi ((My save is with my charas right in front of Gatomon ready to access WiFi))